PROPERTY
PERPETUITY
Log inSign up

Landlords · Originally published · Updated · 2 min read

Missing keys at the end of a tenancy: what evidence supports a charge?

Record what was issued and what came back. Check the tenancy terms, reasonable replacement costs and the deposit scheme’s dispute process.

Property Perpetuity editorial illustration for “Missing keys at the end of a tenancy: what evidence supports a charge?” — propertyperpetuity.com
Illustrative artwork · Property Perpetuity

Sign in to save this for later →

Facebook ↗LinkedIn ↗

If a tenant returns fewer keys than they received, begin with the check-in record and the tenancy agreement. England’s statutory Tenant Fees Act guidance distinguishes a lost-key default fee from a deduction proposed at the end of a tenancy. A lost-key fee needs an express term and evidence of the reasonable costs incurred. If the issue is raised through a protected deposit, the landlord should explain the basis of the deduction and supply evidence for the amount claimed.

Check the keys and the record

Compare the signed inventory with the keys or fobs returned. If an entry is unclear, ask both sides what was issued and whether any keys were replaced during the tenancy. Include common entrance fobs, garage remotes and any device belonging to a building manager. Give the tenant an opportunity to find or return a missing item before ordering work where timing and security allow.

Explain what replacement involves

Ask the locksmith or building manager for an itemised quote. If the loss can be addressed by cutting a replacement or deactivating a fob, record that option. If you think more extensive work is needed, explain why it is proportionate to the security risk and keep the supporting advice. The evidence should show how the missing device led to the expense. A generic fee schedule gives less information than a record of the work actually needed at the address.

Handle a disagreement through the right route

Provide the tenant with the inventory entry, checkout record and any invoice or other evidence. If the deposit is protected and the parties disagree about a deduction, check the scheme’s dispute process and deadlines. Keep copies of the tenant’s replies as well as the landlord’s records. If the item turns up or the building manager confirms it can be disabled cheaply, update the amount you are asking for. The dispute should be based on the documented loss, not simply on the fact that a key was initially unaccounted for.

Reference source ↗